The
summer months are often bleak and arid
in Washington, with Congress out of session
for portions of July and most of August. But the summer of 2007
hotted up in more ways than one, with two Republican sex scandals engendered by members
of the “family values” Senate set.
On July 9 the story broke that Senator David Vitter’s (R-LA)
phone number was included on the infamous “DC Madam” Deborah
Jeanne Palfrey’s call list. According to phone records, Vitter
called her escort service, Pamela Martin & Associates, five times
from 1999 to 2001, while Vitter was still
in the House of Representatives.
This was not the first time Vitter’s name was
associated with prostitution. In 2002 his nascent gubernatorial
campaign in Louisiana was squashed when allegations emerged that
he had been involved with a New Orleans hooker, Wendy Cortez (oddly,
Vitter’s wife is
also named Wendy, which certainly reduces
the chances of embarrassing mistakes during pillow talk). Vitter
withdrew from the race, citing marital difficulties but denying
the accusations. These same allegations were repeated in 2004 when
Vitter ran to fill retiring Senator John Breaux’s seat, but
the Louisiana legislator toughed it out this time, terming the charges “absolutely
and completely untrue,” and “just
crass Louisiana politics.” He went on to win election with 51%
of the vote, becoming the first Republican
ever to be elected to the Senate from Louisiana.
Ironically,
Vitter’s national government career began when he
won a special election in 1999 to replace
disgraced Representative Bob Livingston, who had resigned after an
adultery scandal. Some Louisiana wags have now dubbed this First District
seat “the Something
on the Side” seat. Vitter is a staunch family values supporter,
an opponent of abortion rights and same
sex marriage, and an advocate of abstinence education. He has stated
that “teaching teenagers
that saving sex until marriage and remaining
faithful afterwards is the best choice
for health and happiness.”
With the evidence of the phone records to confront
him, Vitter did not deny his involvement
with the DC escort service, but continued to refute the allegations
of earlier episodes with Wendy Cortez in New Orleans. On July 10,
the day after Hustler magazine
broke the story of his phone calls, Vitter
issued a statement: “This
was a very serious sin in my past for which
I am, of course, completely responsible.
Several years ago, I asked for and received
forgiveness from God and my wife in confession
and marriage counseling. Out of respect for my family, I will keep
my discussion of the matter there—with God and them. But I certainly
offer my deep and sincere apologies to all I have disappointed and
let down in any way.”
After a few days of headlines and controversy, the
story largely died down. The statute of limitations had run on these
infractions dating from the late 90's, and as the conduct had occurred
while Vitter was still in the House, the Senate Ethics Committee
chose not to pursue the matter. Local Louisiana Republicans, though
distressed and offended by Vitter’s behavior, were in a forgiving mood, largely motivated
by the fact that if he resigned, his replacement would be chosen by
Louisiana’s Democratic Governor Kathleen Blanco, thus further
eroding the GOP’s position in the Senate. When Vitter returned
to the Senate floor, he was given a loud
standing ovation by his Republican colleagues.
But another shoe remained to be dropped. Vitter’s
repeated denials over the years had angered Wendy Cortez, the New
Orleans prostitute with whom he was alleged to have had an affair,
and she approached Hustler publisher
Larry Flynt with her story. After passing
a polygraph, on September 11, Cortez and Flynt appeared at a press
conference to reiterate her involvement with Vitter. Cortez affirmed
that over a four-month period in 1999, she and Vitter had regular
sexual assignations, two or three times weekly, at $300 per session.
Vitter’s was not the only performance in the
Republican sexcapades. That same summer a second GOP Senator quite
literally put a foot wrong, and the reaction was very different.
On 27 August 2007, Roll Call, a Washington
DC paper specializing in congressional
news, broke the story that Senator Larry Craig (R-ID) had been arrested
for lewd conduct in a Minneapolis, Minnesota airport men’s
room on June 11, and had plea-bargained to a lesser charge of disorderly
conduct on August 8. As details emerged of his attempts to solicit
sex from a plainclothes policeman in the adjoining bathroom stall,
Craig’s embarrassment became acute, and Senate colleagues
stampeded for the exits.
The Idaho Senator,
another staunch family values proponent
with a long record of opposition to gay rights, such as upholding
the ban on gays in the military, excluding
homosexuals from hate crimes legislation, and supporting a constitutional
amendment to ban gay marriage, had been suspected of gay activity
for 25 years, since the congressional page sex scandal of 1982.
At that time, the 37-year-old Craig was still single, and when journalists
investigated his involvement in the cocaine and sex outrage with
underage male pages, Craig denied it, inveighing, “Persons who are unmarried
as I am, by choice or by circumstance,
have always been the subject of innuendos, gossip and false accusations.
I think this is despicable.” The
following year, Craig married Suzanne Thompson,
and adopted her three children from a previous
marriage; the couple have no children of their own.
While still in the House, Craig was one of several
Republican Ethics Committee members who pushed for sterner measures
against Representative Barney Frank (D-MA) in 1989 for his connection
with a gay prostitution ring. In 1999, as a Senator, Craig came
out strongly against Clinton’s
extramarital affair, leeringly characterizing
him in a Meet The
Press interview that January as “a nasty, bad, naughty
boy.”
On June 11, 2007, during a layover at the Minneapolis
Airport, Craig was arrested after surreptitiously signaling for
sex to an officer who was staked out in the men’s room, notorious for its public
sex. The officer’s report, released to the media, details how
Craig first repeatedly peered through a crack in the officer’s
stall door, then entered the adjoining stall. The Senator tapped his
foot several times in a known gesture of sexual solicitation, then
edged his right foot beneath the partition to nudge the officer’s
left foot, afterward passing his left hand, palm side up, several
times below the partition on the officer’s side.
When shown the officer’s badge and signaled to leave the restroom,
Craig at first refused, then complied. Before his arrest interview,
he presented his Senate ID with the comment, “What do you think
of that?” Craig’s defense of his actions was to assert,
in re the foot touching, that he has a “wide stance” when
using the toilet, and his suggestion that he had lowered his hand
merely to pick up a piece of paper was belied by the use of the left
hand on his extreme right side, which would have been a very awkward
movement given his seated position, and its palm up orientation. That
it was his left hand is confirmed by the officer’s testimony
that when Craig passed it under the stall divider, he could see the
Senator’s wedding ring.
After waiting nearly two months, Craig pled guilty to the reduced
charge of disorderly conduct on August 1, his plea being entered by
mail and registered in Minneapolis on August 8. The day after the
story broke on August 27, the Idaho Statesman, a Boise newspaper,
published an expose of the Senator’s sexual history which they
had been compiling for months, including allegations by three men
that Craig had solicited or performed sexual acts with them. One dated
from 1967, offered by a straight pledge at Craig’s University
of Idaho fraternity, stating that Craig had lured him to his bedroom
and propositioned him; a second allegation stems from a November 1994
incident at an R.E.I. store in Boise, wherein a gay man stated that
Craig cruised him for half an hour, following him around the store;
the third occurrence relates to another incident of public sex at
a men’s room in Washington’s Union Station in 2004, where
a second gay man alleges he and Craig performed
oral sex on each other.
That same day Craig held a press conference in Boise,
where he opened with the rather ill-considered sentiment, “Thank you all for
coming out today.” He further stated that, “I am not gay.
I never have been gay.... In June, I overreacted
and made a poor decision. In hindsight, I should not have pled guilty....
I was trying to handle this matter myself quickly and expeditiously.
I chose to plead guilty to a lesser charge in hopes of making it go
away.... Please let me apologize to my family, friends and staff and
fellow Idahoans for the cloud placed over Idaho. I did nothing wrong
at the Minneapolis airport. I did nothing wrong, and I regret the
decision to plead guilty and the sadness that decision has brought
on my wife, on my family, friends, staff and fellow Idahoans.”
Senate colleagues, with visions before their eyes
of Florida Representative Mark Foley’s disgrace and resignation
just 11 months before in a scandal involving sexually explicit emails
to underage male pages, began backing away immediately. On the 30th
the Statesman called
for Craig’s resignation, followed by fellow GOP Senators John
McCain (R-AZ), Norm Coleman (R-MN) and
Susan Collins (R-ME). Senate Republican leaders stripped Craig of
his committee assignments, and the Ethics Committee mooted an investigation.
On1 September Craig gave another press conference,
announcing his “intent” to
resign his Senate seat effective 30 September.
In a bizarre twist, several days later
an audio tape was released which made
it clear that Craig’s
words were carefully chosen to allow
for an eventual reversal of that apparently final decision. Craig
misdialed when phoning his lawyer, and left a message on a stranger’s
cell phone (later released to the media), stating his true
intention to attempt to have his guilty
plea revoked and to fight for his seat.
Craig’s staff
confirmed this, and on September 10 papers
were filed with a Minneapolis court to
reverse the plea. A hearing was set for
26 September.
Both Vitter and Craig have prominent positions in
the campaigns of current GOP presidential contenders, Vitter as
Regional Southern Chair for Rudy Giuliani, and Craig as Senate Liaison
for Mitt Romney. Giuliani has thus far stood by Vitter, though the
Louisiana Senator has been largely sidelined by the campaign; Romney
ejected Craig almost immediately, stating “He’s disappointed
the American people.”
Born 3 May 1961, David Vitter has a chart well calculated
to provoke controversy. The Sun at 13
Taurus is within the event horizon, or
orb of influence, of the Black Hole at
16 Taurus, and is exactly squared the
volatile Maser at 13 Leo, as well as
being opposed one Pulsar at 15 Scorpio and squared a second at 15
Aquarius. The Black Hole can indicate a second life, a secret, unknown
existence which is at extreme variance with the public face the
native presents. There is also a tendency for Dame Fortune to turn
on a dime, for life to change in the twinkling of an eye. The Maser
indicates a potential for controversy or disruption and lends an
element of shock, while the dual Pulsar contact virtually ensures
the media’s
involvement and interest. Mercury and
asteroid Phaeton are closely conjoined
the Sun from 14 Taurus, subjecting them
to the same galactic influences. Mercury
with a Black Hole can suggest dissembling and avoidance of the truth.
Phaeton here indicates a certain degree of rashness, of biting off
more than one can chew, a precipitate rush into situations one is
not prepared for.
This combination is tightly squared by asteroid Damocles, exactly
conjunct the Pulsar at 15 Aquarius. A sense of impending doom pervades
the situation, which is rife with the constant tension of waiting
for the other shoe to drop.
Sexual astrological indicators are also telling.
Venus at 12 Aries had just made its direct
station the day before Vitter’s birth,
so it is a prominent and potent presence
in the chart. It conjoins the manifestation-evoking Quasar at 10
Aries, which is exactly conjunct minor planet Eris and asteroid
Chaos. Quasar contacts promote visibility and notoriety, and while
this is often a positive outcome, it can have its drawbacks as well,
as seen in Vitter’s case—it is
romantic entanglements that have vaulted
him into the national spotlight.
Eris is a fractious, irritable,
petulant energy (see September
2007 for more on Eris). Its alliance with Venus
and the effect on Vitter’s
relationships here may be noted in the
tenor of Wendy Vitter’s
earlier 1999 remarks concerning potential
marital infidelity. At the time that
Vitter replaced Livingston, who had resigned
his House seat after the disclosure of
his adultery, Wendy was asked if she
could forgive similar conduct by her
husband, the way Livingston’s
wife had forgiven him. Her response was
to state that she was “a
lot more like Lorena Bobbitt than Hillary
[Clinton (then embroiled in the Lewinsky
scandal)]. If he does something like
that, I’m
walking away with one thing, and it’s not
alimony, trust me.” Chaos of course needs no explanation - its
effects on Venus show quite clearly in
Vitter’s life.
Mars, too, is well placed for drama. At 28 Cancer
it is exactly conjoined a Black Hole,
and also conjunct the USA Mercury at
24 Cancer, guaranteeing national headlines
for any revealed sexual irregularities.
Black Hole Mars can be obsessive about sex, and fetishist. (Although
Wendy Cortez has described Vitter as “normal” sexually,
it may be difficult to determine what
constitutes normalcy for a woman of her
experience.) There are very strong appetites
and uncontrollable attractions for practices others might consider
unorthodox or out of the mainstream. Mars also opposes natal Saturn
at 29 Capricorn, itself conjunct another Media-attracting Pulsar;
sexual blocks and frustrations may be indicated, as well as the
implication of sex-as-business and the unfortunate combination of
sexual matters with career.
There is also an interesting T-Square involving Jupiter at 6 Aquarius,
squared to both Neptune at 9 Scorpio conjoined asteroid Eros at 7
and a Black Hole at 6, and asteroid Askalaphus at 5 Taurus, conjunct
the Quasar at 4. Jupiter/Neptune indicates some deception or dissociation
in political matters, specifically involving philosophy, a fundamental
split between the fantasy of what is promulgated and the reality of
what is lived. Black Hole Neptune has a very developed fantasy life,
which tied with Eros highly romanticizes erotic content, and can also
indicate an addictive nature as regards physical passion.
Askalaphus is named for the Underworld denizen who
exposed Persephone’s
consumption of a few pomegranate seeds while in Hades’ enforced
custody, thus requiring her to spend six months of every year with
him. Her mother Demeter was so incensed at his disclosure that she
turned him into a screech owl. There is certainly a tale-bearing aspect
to Vitter’s circumstances, from the original media reports which
have dogged him for almost a decade, to
the DC Madam’s call
list, and lately, Wendy Cortez’ own eyewitness testimony. The
successive build-up of the circumstances
from disputed allegation to uncontested fact may be due to the Quasar
contact, which promotes visibility and shines a spotlight on whatever
it contacts; it is impossible to hide or disguise for long anything
a Quasar touches.
Asteroids Aphrodite and Icarus conjoin at 18 and
16 Pisces, conjunct Uranus’ most recent retrograde station at 18 Pisces in June.
Vitter is a sexual risk-taker, rash and impetuous, and the Uranus
station just two weeks before the story broke was the signal for public
revelations of his indiscretions. Lastly, asteroid Karma at 3 Pisces
exactly conjoins the South Node, an apt image of one’s past
catching up with them; this degree was
highlighted by the August 28 Lunar Eclipse at 4 Pisces.
When the story broke nationally on July 9, 2007,
transit Mars at 10 Taurus was coming to conjoin the Sun/Mercury/Phaeton
combination at 13 and 14 Taurus, and transit Uranus was still at
its station degree of 18 Pisces, highlighting Aphrodite/Icarus.
When Wendy Cortez came forward on 11 September, the transit Sun
at 18 Virgo had moved to oppose Aphrodite/Icarus, with retrograde
Uranus now exactly conjoined Icarus at 16 Pisces. Transit Venus,
fresh from her direct station at 16 Leo, was conjunct the 13 Leo
Maser, inconjunct transit Uranus, and squaring natal Sun/Mercury/Phaeton,
while Saturn at 1 Virgo was bearing down upon Karma/South Node at
3. So far Vitter has not responded directly to Cortez’ accusations,
stating only that these matters have already been addressed.
Craig’s chart is similarly evocative of his
troubles. He was born 20 July 1945. In
his chart, the Sun at 27 Cancer conjoins
the Black Hole at 28 Cancer, squares
two others, at 28 Libra and 26 Aries,
and opposes two Pulsars, at 26 and 28
Capricorn. As with Vitter, Black Hole
Sun can denote separate lives, one open
and above-board, the other hidden and beneath the surface.
Craig’s
ability to successfully compartmentalize
and keep these disparate realities separate
is seriously impinged by the all-seeing
eye of the media, as represented by the
opposed Pulsars. It may have taken 25
years for supposition and innuendo to
be confirmed, but in the final analysis,
Craig was unable to maintain both his
worlds intact.
Venus at 13 Gemini conjoins Uranus at 15; outer planet
contacts with Venus or Mars often denote
same sex attraction, and Venus blended
with Uranus can suggest a desire for the sort of romantic detachment
to be found in anonymous encounters with strangers. Venus/Uranus
natives also tend to form what others consider mesalliances—choosing
partners who are seen as inappropriate or unsuitable, even forbidden
or taboo.
Venus/Uranus is tightly trine to a clustering of
asteroids which straddle a Black Hole
at 13 Libra and a Quasar at 14 Libra. These comprise Ganymede, named
for Zeus’ cup bearer and boy
toy lover, at 12 Libra; Eros, the god of
erotic passion, also at 12 Libra; and Dionysos, divine
patron of homosexual love in ancient Greece,
at 16 Libra. Dionysos, in particular, is a wild and frenzied energy,
unwilling to conform to societal norms, and all too ready to break
the rules and take a risk, exulting in passion run amok. Filling
in a Grand Trine is asteroid Icarus at 14 Aquarius retrograde, suggestive
of an impulsive, impetuous, reactive nature, pursuing a course of
action without thinking through its ramifications, oblivious to
the consequences. Venus/Uranus is also opposed the asteroid Askalaphus
at 14 Sagittarius retrograde, transforming the Grand Trine into
a Kite and repeating the prominent theme of tale-bearing seen in
Vitter’s chart.
Adding fuel to that fire is Mars, which at 28 Taurus
is conjoined a Maser at 26, opposed a
Quasar at 27 Scorpio and squared a Black Hole at 27 Aquarius. Mars/Maser
is volatile and uncontrolled; its needs are visceral and not susceptible
to rational interference. Masers also attract controversy and have
an inescapable, obsessive quality—this deep space anomaly randomly
and violently spews vast jets of matter from its core; when in active
mode it is irrepressible and anarchic. The square to a Black Hole
is again suggestive of hidden matters involving sexuality, or a
parallel reality running unseen side by side the official one. The
Quasar opposition illumines the situation, making permanent obfuscation
impossible, and guaranteeing a high-profile denouement once the
deception is exposed.
As with Venus, Mars is also tied to a number of asteroids
which speak to the specifics of Craig’s situation. Karma at 22 Taurus and
Nemesis at 25 Taurus conjoin Mars, adding a flavor of inevitable comeuppance
and receiving one’s just desserts. Also conjunct are Sappho
at 0 Gemini, which often appears linked
with Venus or Mars in charts of homosexuals; and Phaeton at 5 Gemini,
further suggestive of rash or ill-considered action which brings cataclysm
upon the native.
Asteroids Aphrodite and Damocles conjoin at 10 and 8 Pisces retrograde
respectively, opposed the Black Hole at 9 Virgo. This conveys a sense
of an impending doom hanging over the native due to a romantic dalliance,
all the moreso as Aphrodite/Damocles lies in square to Venus/Uranus.
When Craig was arrested at the Minneapolis Airport
on June 11, transit Jupiter retrograde was precisely conjunct Askalaphus
at 14 Sagittarius, igniting the Venus/Uranus Kite and exposing his
hidden life once and for all. The transit Sun at 20 Gemini had passed
over Venus/Uranus during the preceding week, and transit Uranus,
then at 18 Pisces, had been squaring the pair late that winter and
early spring, preparing the ground for a shocking revelation. Transit
Mars and Saturn were joined at 20 Leo, opposing transit Neptune
at 20 Aquarius, this polarity focused on Craig’s natal Mercury at 24 Leo. Neptune’s
ability to obfuscate and delay gave the Senator a couple months’ lead
time on the release of the news (Mercury),
but ultimately, the disclosure of his sexual improprieties (Mars)
may end his career (Saturn).
Craig mailed in his guilty plea on 1 August, with
the transit Sun focused on his 9 Leo natal Pluto, indicating the
scandal, and with Mars at 26 Taurus conjunct Nemesis and about to
return to its natal degree of 28 Taurus, reinforcing the sense,
supported by the testimony of men he approached for sex from college
to the present, that this is a lifelong sexual attraction for men,
not a one-time misunderstanding. When the story broke on 27 August,
newsy Mercury at 14 Virgo was tightly squared natal Venus/Uranus
and forming a T-Square with natal Askalaphus. Mars at 12 Gemini
was moving to conjoin Venus/Uranus, which it finally did by the
end of the week when Craig announced his tentative resignation on
1 September. By then, too, the transit Sun at 8 Virgo was poised
to burn away the slender thread of Damocles’ sword, which it
opposed exactly.
Vitter and Craig are each, of course, entitled to
a private life, and to whatever decisions
they make concerning it. Both are in
some sense a hostage to the moral rectitude
of fundamentalist Christian interests,
which have made common cause with the
GOP, a union which has brought the Republican
Party electoral success. In the ordinary
course of events, their private indiscretions would not merit public
examination, but when politicians tout “family
values” to
receive votes while simultaneously engaging
in some of the behaviors they condemn,
their actions become relevant and public
scrutiny is appropriate. In such circumstances
their hypocrisy is evident, and “values
voters” would do well to consider the effects on our country’s
political discourse wrought by their carping
insistence on strict adherence to their
own arbitrary standards.